thejoe Cass Clay Creamery AMPI Fargo Division

Cass Clay Creamery AMPI Fargo Division: 30 FDA recall reports

Every food recall the FDA has published for Cass Clay Creamery AMPI Fargo Division. The fault, and how the agency graded it.

30Reports

3Class I

0Ongoing

2012-09-05Most recent

3 Class I on this page

Class I means the FDA judged there was a reasonable probability of serious harm or death. Check the lot numbers against anything you hold.

What the classes mean

The FDA sorts every recall into one of three classes. The class is the whole story. It is also the part people skip.

Class	What the FDA is saying
Class I	There is a reasonable probability that using this will cause serious harm or death.
Class II	It may cause temporary or reversible harm. Serious harm is unlikely.
Class III	It breaks a rule but is unlikely to hurt anyone. Often a labelling fault.

Class II is the bulk of every list here. That matters. A long list of Class II says something different from one Class I.

By class

Class	Reports
Class II	26
Class I	3
Class III	1

Checking whether it affects you

The lot or code number is what matters. Not the product name. A recall covers specific lots. Yours may not be one of them.

Check the code on your package against the report. The FDA keeps the current list at fda.gov/safety/recalls.

The reports

The text below is quoted from the FDA record word for word.

Dan's, LIGHT BUTTER PECAN, half gallon *(1.89 L), 0 70422 24210 4 Hornbachers, LIGHT BUTTER PECAN, half gall

F-2044-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Dan's, LIGHT BUTTER PECAN, half gallon *(1.89 L), 0 70422 24210 4 Hornbachers, LIGHT BUTTER PECAN, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 41130 21661 9 Sunnybrook, LIGHT BUTTER PECAN, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 70422 24908 0
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 8,141 containers

CASS CLAY, DULUTH DARK CHOCOLATE, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).

F-2042-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared yellow #5.
Product: CASS CLAY, DULUTH DARK CHOCOLATE, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 36 containers

Cass Clay, TIN ROOF SUNDAE 3 Gallon (11.34 L) Cass Clay, TIN ROOF SUNDAE, one gallon (3.78 L), 0 70422 034

F-2049-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay, TIN ROOF SUNDAE 3 Gallon (11.34 L) Cass Clay, TIN ROOF SUNDAE, one gallon (3.78 L), 0 70422 03474 7
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 9,094 containers

HORNBACHERS, LIGHT FRENCH VANILLA, HALF GALLON (1.89L), 0 41130 21662 6 (Missing Egg from Contains statement)

F-2039-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because labelling of egg ingredient is not FALCPA compliant and for undeclared color Yellow 5.
Product: HORNBACHERS, LIGHT FRENCH VANILLA, HALF GALLON (1.89L), 0 41130 21662 6 (Missing Egg from Contains statement) SUNNYBROOK, LIGHT FRENCH VANILLA, HALF GALLON (1.89 L), 0 70422 24917 2 . (MISSING YELLOW 5 FROM LABEL) DAN'S, LIGHT FRENCH VANILLA, HALF GALLON(1.89 L), 0 70422 24317 0 (MISSING YELLOW 5 FROM LABEL )
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 23,852 containers

HORNBACHERS, FRENCH VANILLA ICE CREAM, Half-gallon (1.89 L), 0 41130 21658 9 (Missing Egg in the Contains sta

F-2062-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because labelling of egg ingredient is not FALCPA compliant.
Product: HORNBACHERS, FRENCH VANILLA ICE CREAM, Half-gallon (1.89 L), 0 41130 21658 9 (Missing Egg in the Contains statement)
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: N/A

CASS-CLAY: LIGHT DUSTY ROAD, ONE GALLON (3.78 L

F-2038-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy lecithin and wheat.
Product: CASS-CLAY: LIGHT DUSTY ROAD, ONE GALLON (3.78 L), 0 70422 23480 2. LIGHT ICE CREAM, DUSTY ROAD, HALF GALLON (1.89L), 0 70422 24080 3
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 6,192 containers

Cass Clay, WINTER WONDER, half gallon (1.89 L) , 0 70422 00100 8 Cass Clay, Winter Wonder, 3 Gallon (11.33

F-2054-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay, WINTER WONDER, half gallon (1.89 L) , 0 70422 00100 8 Cass Clay, Winter Wonder, 3 Gallon (11.334 L)
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 4321 containers

Cass-Clay, COOKIES 'N VANILLA 3 Gallon (11.34 L)

F-2061-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy lecithin.
Product: Cass-Clay, COOKIES 'N VANILLA 3 Gallon (11.34 L)
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: N/A

Cass-Clay , Swiss Chip, 3 Gallon(11.34 L).

F-2057-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass-Clay , Swiss Chip, 3 Gallon(11.34 L).
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 81 containers

Cass Clay, PEPPERMINT CANDY, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 70422 00100 8 Cass Clay, Peppermint Stic, 3 Gallon (

F-2053-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay, PEPPERMINT CANDY, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 70422 00100 8 Cass Clay, Peppermint Stic, 3 Gallon (11.34 L).
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 11,288 containers

Cass Clay CHOCOLATE MONSTER, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 00032 2 Cass Clay CHOCOLATE MONSTER, 3 Gallon (11.3

F-2048-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay CHOCOLATE MONSTER, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 00032 2 Cass Clay CHOCOLATE MONSTER, 3 Gallon (11.34 L) Soy (Lecithin) N/A
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 23,870

Schroeder, Ice Cream, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 72340 00183 2

F-2055-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared wheat.
Product: Schroeder, Ice Cream, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 72340 00183 2
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 2,100 containers

CASS-CLAY, DOUBLE CHOCOLATE FUDGE, Premium Light Ice Cream, HALF GALLON (1.89L), 0 70422 24061 2

F-2036-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy lecithin and peanut oil.
Product: CASS-CLAY, DOUBLE CHOCOLATE FUDGE, Premium Light Ice Cream, HALF GALLON (1.89L), 0 70422 24061 2
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 1,064

Cass-Clay, UND CHAMPION CHIP, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 04062 5 Cass-Clay, UND CHAMPION CHIP 3 Gallon

F-2046-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass-Clay, UND CHAMPION CHIP, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 04062 5 Cass-Clay, UND CHAMPION CHIP 3 Gallon (11.34 L)
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 46 containers

Cass Clay, COOKIES 'N CREAM, 1 gallon ( 3.78 L), 0 70422 45034 9 Cass Clay, COOKIES 'N CREAM, half gallon (1.

F-2037-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy lecithin.
Product: Cass Clay, COOKIES 'N CREAM, 1 gallon ( 3.78 L), 0 70422 45034 9 Cass Clay, COOKIES 'N CREAM, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 70422 04010 6
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 43,089 containers

Cass-Clay, Strawberry Cheesecake, 3 Gallon (11.34 L).

F-2058-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared yellow 5, Yellow 6, Blue 1, Blue 2 and or soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass-Clay, Strawberry Cheesecake, 3 Gallon (11.34 L).
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 443 containers

Cass-Clay, BUTTER PECAN, 3 Gallon (11.34 L)

F-2063-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy lecithin.
Product: Cass-Clay, BUTTER PECAN, 3 Gallon (11.34 L)
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: N/A

SunnyBrook, Chocolate Chip one gallon and one quart ( (4.73 L), 0 70422 02905 7 SunnyBrook, CHOCOLATE CHI

F-2045-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: SunnyBrook, Chocolate Chip one gallon and one quart ( (4.73 L), 0 70422 02905 7 SunnyBrook, CHOCOLATE CHIP half gallon ( (1.89 L), 0 70422 04905 5 Cass Clay, CHOCOLATE CHIP 3 Gallon (11.34 L)
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 11,461 containers

CASS-CLAY, PRALINE PECAN, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).

F-2040-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared yellow #6, and soy (lecithin).
Product: CASS-CLAY, PRALINE PECAN, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 512 containers

SUNNYBROOK, LIGHT COOKIES 'N CREAM, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 70422 24943 1

F-2060-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy lecithin.
Product: SUNNYBROOK, LIGHT COOKIES 'N CREAM, half gallon (1.89 L), 0 70422 24943 1
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: N/A

CASS CLAY, NEW YORK CHERRY ICE CREAM, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).

F-2043-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared yellow #5.
Product: CASS CLAY, NEW YORK CHERRY ICE CREAM, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 119 containers

Class I

CASS-CLAY, Ice Cream, Artificially Flavored MAPLE NUT, One Gallon (3.78 L), 0 70422 03404 4 HORNBACHERS,

F-2035-2012 · Class I · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared Brazil nuts.
Product: CASS-CLAY, Ice Cream, Artificially Flavored MAPLE NUT, One Gallon (3.78 L), 0 70422 03404 4 HORNBACHERS, MAPLE NUT, Ice Cream, HALF GALLON(1.89 L), 0 41130 21666 4 COLUMBIA VALLEY FARMS, MAPLE NUT, 62438, 3 GALLON(11.34L), 0 41493 62438 0
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 22757

CASS-CLAY, BUBBLE GUM, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).

F-2041-2012 · Class III · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared red 40, Blue 1, and Blue 2.
Product: CASS-CLAY, BUBBLE GUM, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 335 containers

Class I

CASS-CLAY, Ice cream, LIGHT MAPLE NUT, One Gallon (3.78L), 0 70422 23404 8

F-2059-2012 · Class I · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared Brazil nuts.
Product: CASS-CLAY, Ice cream, LIGHT MAPLE NUT, One Gallon (3.78L), 0 70422 23404 8
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: N/A

Hornbachers, Peanut Butter Fudge, Half Gallon, (1.89L), 0 41130-21659 6.

F-2056-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because it may contain undeclared peanuts in contains statement. Milk and peanuts listed in ingredient deck, however, only milk listed in contains statement.
Product: Hornbachers, Peanut Butter Fudge, Half Gallon, (1.89L), 0 41130-21659 6.
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 4221 containers

Cass Clay, BISON CRUNCH, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 04033 5 Cass Clay, BISON CRUNCH, 3 Gallon (11.34 L)

F-2050-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay, BISON CRUNCH, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 04033 5 Cass Clay, BISON CRUNCH, 3 Gallon (11.34 L)
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 35,996 containers

Cass Clay, LIGHT CANDY BAR, half gallon (1.89 L ) 0 70422 24032 2

F-2051-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay, LIGHT CANDY BAR, half gallon (1.89 L ) 0 70422 24032 2
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 4,357 containers

Cass Clay, LIGHT BROWNIE FDG, one gallon ( 3.78 L) 0 70422 23485 7 Cass Clay, LIGHT BROWNIE FUDGE, half gallo

F-2047-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay, LIGHT BROWNIE FDG, one gallon ( 3.78 L) 0 70422 23485 7 Cass Clay, LIGHT BROWNIE FUDGE, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 24085 8
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 6390 containers

Cass Clay, LIGHT MUDDY SNEAKERS, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 24072 8

F-2052-2012 · Class II · reported 2012-09-05 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared soy (lecithin).
Product: Cass Clay, LIGHT MUDDY SNEAKERS, half gallon (1.89 L) 0 70422 24072 8
Where it went: ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS
How much: 5,347 containers

Class I

Peppermint Bon Bon Light Ice Cream under the following three brands: Hornbachers, Peppermint Bon Bon Ligh

F-1774-2012 · Class I · reported 2012-08-01 · Terminated

Why it was recalled: The ice cream products may contain undeclared eggs. A flavoring containing egg yolks was used as an ingredient in the products, and the ingredient statement on the product package did not reveal the presence of eggs.
Product: Peppermint Bon Bon Light Ice Cream under the following three brands: Hornbachers, Peppermint Bon Bon Light Ice Cream, Half Gallon (1.89 L), UPC 41130-21663, Distributed by Supervalu Inc, Eden Prairie, MN 55344. SunnyBrook, Peppermint Bon Bon Light Ice Cream, Half Gallon (1.89 L), UPC 70422-24919, Distributed by Mason Brothers Co., Wadena, MN 56482. Schroeder, Peppermint Bon Bon Ice cream, 56 oz or 1.75 Qt (1.65 L) 3 , UPC 72340-00193, Schroeder Company, Maplewood, MN 55113
Where it went: MN, WI, ND and IA
How much: 2492 units

Read these counts with three things in mind

A firm with more recalls usually makes more products. A contract packer runs hundreds of lines. It will out-recall a company with one product whatever either does. This is not a safety ranking.

Most recalls here are voluntary. A firm found its own fault and pulled the stock. That is the system working. It lands in this database looking the same as a recall the FDA had to push for.

Terminated means the FDA considers the recall finished. It is not a verdict. It does not mean anyone was harmed.

Source: openFDA enforcement reports, retrieved 2026-08-05. FDA dataset last updated 2026-07-29.

← All food recalls